Although he has written what is without a doubt my favorite book on the craft of writing,
Writing the Breakout Novel, Donald Maass has not written my favorite article in
Writer Unboxed with his effort titled
The New Class System.
Although there are several points I agree with, among them:
e-books have not hurt the print publishers but rather have helped them. Especially in the recent recession, low-cost/high-margin e-books have been a bright spot. They’ve kept publishers profitable even as brick-and-mortar book retailing has shrunk and consumers have grown cautious.
and
Second, the self-publishing movement has been a boon to the print industry. Far from being threatened, print publishers instead are now gratefully relieved of the money-losing burden of the mid-list.
I don't agree with this snippet:
High success at self-publishing has happened only for a few who have mastered the demanding business of online marketing.
I think there are far more authors out there who have found success in the self-publishing world over and above just those who have mastered the business of online marketing. Just as there are videos out there that go "viral" so have some books. The one that pops to mind first is
Wool. That sucker got started from pure word of mouth and good reviews. I think the same could be said for Diane Gabaldon's
Outlander series.
Maass then goes on to discuss the new class system in publishing as he see's it; Freight, Coach and First Classes. If I am on the train at all (doubtful) then I am firmly in the freight class. I aspire to Coach, and think with each new effort I get closer to it.
My writing buddy
Kristi (who first told me about this article) intoned that she wasn't too much pleased with the conclusions, but it actually tends to follow the model that Donald Maass wrote about in
Writing the Breakout Novel. Although I may not have said it succinctly, or at all, in my
review of the book it comes across (as I recall) quite clearly. Maass seems to believe that if an author has not achieved that breakout novel, a well-written, engaging, intriguing better than the rest book by their third published effort than it's time to pack it in and try something else.
I don't believe that. If the past few novels I've written have shown me anything it's that my writing gets better with each draft. At this pace where will I be when I'm 50? (Speaking of 50 year olds, my new favorite author (more on this in coming days) didn't publish his first book until he was 50 and then went on to greater and greater success. Stay tuned for more on that!)
Maass does leave himself an out. He says near the end of the article:
In the world of publishing, though, it’s not like that. Authorship is a true meritocracy. (Sorry, it is.) In publishing there is social mobility. As an author you can change your class, though of course it’s not always easy to do so. It takes education, time and effort. It means seeing yourself differently, having courage and violating the norms and expectations of your community. (One of the most common laments I hear is, “I got published…and lost a lot of my friends.”)
What class will I be in when I'm 50? I hope I'm firmly in coach.
Keep in mind, in terms of railroads there's no money in passenger travel, look out how many passenger train business models fail,
is Amtrak a success? Name one passenger rail system that is as profitable as freight (see
here). Freight is where the big money is. Go ask Warren Buffet. Maybe I should be happy with Freight class and find some way to make money off all the other Freighters out there working the keys with me.
Still,
The New Class System is an interesting view into the world of the publisher and as always I would highly recommend his book,
Writing the Breakout Novel.